Yes, you read correctly. I am going to commit the ultimate single man's offense. I'm going to give parenting advice. So I was driving down the road and I heard a one of those fix-your-kids parenting tips on Christian radio. The expert on all things childly said that instead of saying, "Johnny, don't do that or I'll..." you should say, "Johnny, if you choose to do this, then you will have to accept ____ punishment." This way the child learns important decision-making skills that will serve him later in life. I thought to myself, "I guess that makes sense" and kept driving.
Fast forward three days. Once again I was riding in the car, and my mind wandered back to what I had heard. And I realized that it was misguided. The psychologist's suggested language changes the child's reason for obedience, and it isn't a good change. In the first situation, the child must do what I say, because I am mom and I said so. In the second situation, the child is expected to decide that the punishment is not worth the temporary pleasure of disobedience. The parent surrenders most of his or her authority.
What happens five years down the road? Rather than respecting his teacher because of her authority, he decides that the attention he gets from lipping off far exceeds the punishment of getting sent to the principle's office.
Ten years down the road? Rather than driving the speed limit because that is the law and laws are meant to be obeyed, the new and inexperienced driver decides that he has $150 in the bank in case he gets a speeding ticket, so who cares?
Twenty years down the road? "Dr. Drake is such a jerk. He kicked me out of the class just because I copied Samantha's answers on the quiz. It's just a stupid quiz; It's barely even worth anything!"
Twenty five years down the road? What else is worth the fine? Drunk driving? Corporate theft? Adultery? Something worse? I am reminded of what Randy Moss said after he tried to run over a parking attendant who made him mad. Somebody asked him what he thought of the fine and said that you don't even write a check for something like that; it's pocket change. He got kicked off of an NFL team because of his complete lack of respect for authority, and I think it surprised him enough that he finally learned something. Too bad nobody instilled it in him sooner.
L'Abeille Boutique
7 years ago